«Many are at their limit»

Time: 3 min

«Many are at their limit»

Marianne Schwegler, 50, is a special education teacher in Basel-Stadt. Integrative schools are reaching their limits and jeopardising the health of teachers, she says. A popular initiative, which she helped to launch, aims to remedy the situation.

Images: Ornella Cacace / 13Photo

Recorded by Virginia Nolan

"I am Vice President of the Basel Voluntary School Synod, the professional association of teachers and specialists with over 4,000 members. Last late summer, the majority of them launched a popular initiative that caused quite a stir: Basel teachers wanted to abolish integration, according to the media. The opposite is the case: we want to strengthen inclusive schools - by providing urgently needed relief for mainstream classes.

Four children per class are considered to have behavioural problems. We don't have enough resources to cushion this. The children are the ones who suffer.

We are calling for special education classes to be introduced in mainstream schools in Basel. For children who learn better in small groups and those whose behaviour goes beyond the scope of a regular class. The aim of the remedial class would be for children to stabilise and return to their mainstream class in the long term.

Many teachers are at their limit. In Basel-Stadt, the resources that schools have for integrative support are often not nearly enough to cope with the associated challenges. A survey conducted by our association shows that one of the biggest stress factors is dealing with behavioural problems.

We are increasingly dealing with children who are developmentally delayed in the socio-emotional area and are at the level of a toddler in kindergarten. They throw themselves on the floor and scream when they are overstimulated, hit or kick when they encounter resistance. I observe this kind of behaviour right through to primary school.

Here, too, more and more children lack strategies for dealing with frustration, anger or distraction. Most of them come from socially disadvantaged families. At my level, many have no or no diagnosis that would enable them to access additional resources.

In the past, children with disabilities or learning or behavioural problems attended special schools; today, they attend mainstream schools whenever possible. What supporters praise as a social achievement is seen by critics as a test for the school system. What can inclusion really achieve and what not? Read more in the article «One school for all?».

As a special needs teacher, I accompany my class from the first to the third primary level. In the first class, I can support the teacher with five weekly lessons of integrative support; in the third class, it's three. According to studies, 20 per cent of children are considered to have behavioural problems, up to four children per class. We don't have enough resources to cushion this. The children are the ones who suffer. The ones whose needs go beyond the scope - and the less conspicuous ones who miss out.

In most cases, these are ready-to-go children who are weaker at school and need a little more support, or cognitively fit foreign speakers who do not understand everything in German. However, children often do not report a need for support on their own; they are dependent on the teacher or special needs teacher recognising it. That's difficult to do when you're constantly absorbed in putting out fires elsewhere."

The 11 most important terms for inclusion:

What exactly does special educational needs mean and what is meant by integrative support? We have compiled a glossary for you with the most important terms relating to special educational measures at primary school. You can find out more here.
This text was originally published in German and was automatically translated using artificial intelligence. Please let us know if the text is incorrect or misleading: feedback@fritzundfraenzi.ch